Illustrative figures, not client data. Net revenue for October. October’s completed orders total €120,000. €5,000 of refunds were issued in October on October orders, €4,000 in October on September orders, and €3,000 in November on October orders.
| Definition | Rule | Working | Net revenue |
|---|---|---|---|
| Definition A: refunds belong to the month they are issued | Subtract every refund issued in October. | €120,000 − €5,000 − €4,000 | €111,000, final when October closes |
| Definition B: refunds belong to the month of the original order | Subtract every refund on an October order, whenever it was issued. | €120,000 − €5,000 − €3,000 | €112,000 by the end of November, and it can still move later |
Neither team is wrong, and both numbers come from the same tables. Until the refund timing is written down and approved, the finance pack and the product dashboard will disagree every month, and someone will be asked to “fix” whichever one is in front of them.